The SFC and SEHK provided clarifications on a number of issues, such as guidance for issuers who are unable to publish a preliminary results announcement in accordance with the . For a given scenario, identify if there is regulatory noncompliance and the SPS regulation that was not met. No, the license must have been active when the incident occured. In its recent statement, FDA did not elaborate on whether the other recipients of the Pre-Notices of Noncompliance have taken action to comply with the requirements. 1:43 pm junio 7, 2022. shopko safety glasses. Which applies? 2020 Penalty Amount. A claim will be denied if the offending licensee had an expired license at the time of the transaction. Not less than two (2) or more than 10 times the claimant's weekly benefit amount. that, if this certification is false, such false certification will constitute grounds for the State to terminate this Agreement. Sharing perspectives and personal experiences of noncompliance with academic ethics is not a favorable topic of discussion amongst faculty members. Civil liability for willful noncompliance [15 U.S.C. Who renders a determination as to whether probable cause exists? A Consequence of SCRA Noncompliance. 4) Wait for the recommended order that will come in the mail, Correct the minor infraction with 15 days, Question 4 (1 point) The answer is COMMINGLING. The DBPR is authorized to issue fines of up to $5,000 per count to a person it finds guilty of unlicensed activity. True or false,Criminal penalties for violating license law as a 3rd felony can result in a $10,000 fine and up to five years in prison. Who renders a determination as to whether probable cause exists? This requirement is duplicative and unnecessary, as certifying agents (when issuing a notice of noncompliance) must specify a date by which a certified operation must rebut or correct noncompliances (Sec. Hence, you are in a breach of the contract. The licensee-respondent may challenge the final order within 30 days by filing a petition for judicial review. Address the letter to the person at the organization who either requested the letter or who is in charge of monitoring compliance. Which penalty is NOT an administrative penalty that may be imposed by the FREC? A broker who fails to pay an earnest money deposit at the title closing in accordance with the contract for sale and purchase may be charged with which offense? The licensee has signed the election of rights indicating that he does not dispute the allegations of fact and he requests an informal hearing. Which offense is a misdemeanor of the first degree? (To find out how you can learn what specific information a business has collected about you, see the Right to Know section .) The FREC may issue a summary suspension when a licensee's actions endanger the public. How much could it cost your organization if you do not get control of this issue? It is composed of 2 current members or one current and one former member of the FREC 616. Which statement is FALSE regarding the fund? if a party believes that the other party has not complied with any provision of this agreement, that party shall provide the other party with notice of non - compliance containing the following information: (i) the alleged act of non-compliance; (ii) a reference to the specific provision (s) of the settlement agreement or confidential addendum These civil penalties can be staggering $55,000 for the first violation and $110,000 for subsequent violations. If a real estate licensee violates the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice for the second time, the Commission may impose a penalty of $1,000 to $5,000 administrative fine and suspension to revocation. If the customer is unable to collect on the judgement, can the customer be reimbursed from the Real Estate Recovery Fund? which statement is false regarding a notice of noncompliance? Noncompliance with ethics is a sensitive topic for research. Did correct an error or omission on an application A sales associate received a $5,000 earnest money deposit from a buyer. The wrong doing by the licensee results in immediate revocation of the licensee, The wrong doing by the licensee results in immediate revocation of the licensee, Question 5 (1 point) What's wrong with this Proposed Suspension? He thought the rules must have changed! Did not prove qualifications for licensure, Did correct an error or omission on an application, When a complaint is received, the department may provide a licensee with a notice of noncompliance under all of the following conditions except The statement is FALSE. While the investor was on vacation, the sales associate took a two-week vacation but still returned several days ahead of the investor. Which statement is FALSE regarding the . Even Attempts Violate SCRA The Noncompliance Statement below identifies the violation(s) of the child welfare statute and / or administrative rule identified by the licensing specialist(s). Broker Teddy Bear was given a notice of noncompliance. Which statement applies to the situation? Notify Dwayne of the error, cancel his license, and inform Dwayne that he could resume the steps toward licensing. The Court will send a Noncompliance letter when an item is not in the court file by that date. This form is used by the Landlord to notify a residential Tenant of a breach of the lease due to material non-compliance with the lease provisions. XXXXXX XXXX sent notification of non-compliance on 10/18/2011 with options in order to resolve the noncompliance, as of this date XXXXXX 8. The potential risk involved in this area is far-reaching. Terminate the engagement with sufficient notice given to the client. How much can the buyer receive from the Recovery Fund? The Enforcement Division initiates civil penalty actions under the statutory authority cited in 14 C.F.R. ESTIMATE OF COST . A licensee who receives a notice of noncompliance for a minor violation must take action to correct the violation within 15 days. Address the letter to the person at the organization who either requested the letter or who is in charge of monitoring compliance. Location: South Puget Sound Region- Enumclaw, WA. When a complaint is received, the department may provide a licensee with a notice of noncompliance under all of the following conditions except 1) The complaint does not demonstrate a serious inability to practice the profession 2) The complaint did not result in economic or physical harm to a person . False Statement Penalty 1142(a) Making a false statement or representation or willfully failing to report a material fact regarding the termination of an employee's employment. About Grupo . The correct answer is A. The Agency's core mission and role in support of U.S. foreign policy and national security objectives requires that we work in a wide variety of high-threat environments, with risks ranging from state failure and armed conflict in the most "fragile" contexts to corruption . Get information about false and misleading advertising, contests, performance claims, multi-level marketing and telemarketing. A licensee who receives a notice of noncompliance for a minor violation must take action to correct the violation within 15 days. The Florida Real Estate Recovery Fund provides compensation to members of the public who have been defrauded or suffered financial harm as the result of culpable negligence, by a real estate licensee in a housing transaction. The Georgia broker contacts a Florida broker to help locate some suitable tracts for the prospect to consider. The DBPR may issue which penalty for an initial offense of a minor violation by a licensee? Which statement is false regarding the probable cause panel? How much can the buyer recover from the Fund? The commission is authorized to pay, Arthur Getis, Daniel Montello, Mark Bjelland, Marketing Essentials: The Deca Connection, Carl A. Woloszyk, Grady Kimbrell, Lois Schneider Farese, Find the percentage. Until that time, the interim final rule remains in effect. The broker defrauds the buyer of the $53,500. Under Florida Statute 455, which penalty may be imposed on an individual for unlicensed practice of real estate? 0. which statement is false regarding a notice of noncompliance? The complainant is the person who files the complaint. AREA OF NONCOMPLIANCE: DBE, EEO/AA, OJT, or WAGES DOCUMENT OR REQUIREMENT: DOCUMENT & FORM NO.OR DESCRIPTION OF REQUIREMENT REPORTING TIMEFRAME: SPECIFIC STATEMENT (REPEAT FOR EACH CONTRACTOR &/OR AREA OF NONCOMPLIANCE) This noncompliance is to be resolved by the close of business on mm/dd/yy. The aggrieved party can recover up to $50,000.00 for a single case of misconduct Explain the Walt Disney Companys diversification strategy in 2012. While investigating a complaint against licensee Dee, the DBPR discovered facts believed to be so grave as to endanger the public if Dee was allowed to practice real estate while under investigation. The licensee used the sign as a way to reach prospective buyers for his listed properties. What legal basis did the investor have for her suit? statements, and those in business. What is your conclusion? Find the absolute maximum and absolute minimum (if any) of the given function on the specified interval. The DBPR Secretary can issue a stipulation against Dee Zaster 1) Negotiate a stipulation order with the lawyer of the DRE (1) The plan administrator files a standard termination notice under 4041.25 and the PBGC does not issue a notice of noncompliance pursuant to 4041.31 (a); and. Browse over 1 million classes created by top students, professors, publishers, and experts. The answer is 30. (A) any actual damages sustained by the consumer as a result of the failure or damages . False Statement Penalty 1142(a) Making a false statement or representation or willfully failing to report a material fact regarding the termination of an employee's employment. The FAA has authority to issue orders assessing a civil penalty of up to $400,000 against persons other than individuals and small business concerns and up to $50,000 against individuals and small business concerns. Time will tell if additional enforcement actions follow. The answer is SELLER. She has been informed that the license has been revoked. Labelling. They are not presently indicted for or otherwise . The answer is $7,000. The answer is 30. This problem can produce minimal damage if an organization has information security audits periodically. Which violation is a third-degree felony for a real estate licensee? The FREC may issue a summary suspension when a licensee's actions endanger the public. A broker followed the instructions of an escrow disbursement order. which statement is false regarding a notice of noncompliance?sigma female examples Call (225) 687-7590 or + 14moretakeoutloving hut vegan house, dophert, and more today! If a complaint has been filed against a licensee and the licensee is not disputing any material facts, then the case can be presented in an informal hearing before the FREC. Litigation damages; Imprisonment Their cooperation pays off when the buyer purchases a 60-acre tract for $558,000 and they evenly divide a 10% commission. b. True false, A licensee that has had a complaint filed against him or her can voluntarily surrender or relinquish their license instead of facing disciplinary action. If the penalty would suspend or revoke a license, however, the court will normally grant supersedes (stay suspension) as a matter or right on conditions considered reasonable. Which is most correct? With thanks. 2021 Penalty Amount. A court awarded a judgement against a broker for $30,000 actual damages and for $45,000 punitive damages regarding a real estate brokerage transaction. Failure to take corrective action may result in a fine or other disciplinary penalties. Which legal term applies to this situation? Best judgement assessment is applied where a dispute occurs over the taxability of a certain source of income. A licensee has 15 days to take action to correct a violation stipulated in a notice of noncompliance. The investor promised to decide on a site in three weeks, so the broker took a two-week vacation. Sharing perspectives and personal experiences of noncompliance with academic ethics is not a favorable topic of discussion amongst faculty members. A non-compliance notice can be useful for protecting your property and may be one of the first steps toward eviction notices if your tenant remains non-compliant. A limitation of this study was an unwillingness of some participants to share their experiences entirely. Did correct an error or omission on an application. A complaint is legally sufficient if it appears to have violated: When a complaint is received, the department may provide a licensee with a notice of noncompliance under all of the following conditions except: There is only one other complaint on record for the offense. The FREC may discipline a broker for accepting a postdated check that becomes uncollectible due to no fault of the broker. True or false, if a complaint has been filed against a licensee and the licensee is not disputing any material facts, then the case can be presented in an informal hearing before the FREC. Which expense may NOT be reimbursed from the Fund? process of determining ell program eligibility in arizona. But once the DBPR realized that several licenses were issued in error, what action would the DBPR take? Forward-looking statements are subject to numerous conditions, many of which are beyond the control of the Company, including those set forth in the Risk Factors section of the Company's . Any person who willfully fails to comply with any requirement imposed. An outline of the charges against a licensee that must be answered within the statutory time limit, A complaint that contains facts indicating that a violation of a Florida statute, a DBPR rule, or a FREC rule has occurred, An agreement as to the penalty reached between the attorneys for the DRE and the licensee or licensee's attorney, A session in which testimony and arguments are presented, especially before an official, A respondent who does not dispute allegations of material fact in the administrative complaint may request an informal hearing before the FREC for final action on the complaint, The intent to misrepresent a material fact or to deceive in order to gain an unfair advantage or to harm another person. The spouse of a judgment debtor is qualified to make a claim from the Real Estate Recovery Fund. It stated that, although the contractor had disclosed some information regarding noncompliance with the cybersecurity requirements to the government, the extent of the disclosures was unclear, and the government may not have had the "full picture" of the contractor's noncompliance. The consumer-plaintiff obtained a judgment against the licensed real estate broker. Payment for their claims, in the aggregate, is limited to. A piece of information that affects the value of real property and is relevant to a person making a decision about that property. We make safe shipping arrangements for your convenience from Baton Rouge, Louisiana What is Non-compliance Eviction? A bank is willing to lend money at 6% interest, compounded annually. Question 1 (2 points) V Saved True or false: The impacts of regulations and other initiatives are immediately realized. As a result of significant concerns across most stakeholder groups regarding the . Neither the sales associate or the investor was aware that, during their vacations, the zoning for the property had been changed from multifamily to single family zoning, thereby prohibiting the use of the property the investor had intended. Which statement is TRUE? An audit in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards normally includes audit procedures. 2) The complaint did not result in economic or physical harm to a person Which action would NOT result in a denial of an application? Full-time, Permanent, Represented position. True or false, a licensee that participated in the subject transaction as an agent is not entitled to make a claim for an unpaid commission against the recovery fund. It relates to fraudulent contracts. September 10, 2018. A customer obtained a judgement against a real estate licensee for negligent conduct involving a real estate brokerage transaction. Suspension of an individual's license is a permanent penalty. reprimand, fine, or otherwise discipline licensees. Description. Which of the following statements concerning noncompliance with laws and regulations by clients is correct? (January 25, 2022) The U.S. Department of Labor's Occupational Safety and Health Administration is withdrawing the vaccination and testing emergency temporary standard issued on Nov. 5, 2021, to protect unvaccinated employees of large employers with 100 or more employees from workplace exposure to coronavirus. How many days does the license have to either pay the citation or file an objection to the alleged violation? Nothing, Dee Zaster is innocent until proven guilty True False The statement is FALSE. The penalty involved with a Citation are fines between $100 to $500. A complaint is LEGALLY SUFFICIENT if it appears to have violated When a consumer files a complaint against a real estate licensee that contains facts indicating that a violation of FREC rules has occurred, the complaint is said to be. B. But penalties for SCRA noncompliance can be severe, and even devastating, depending on the size of your business or institution. Question 13 - All of the following are implicatons of non-compliance with HIPAA, EXCEPT: Financial Penalties; Public exposure that could lead to loss of market share; Answer: Having to file a public notice of non-compliance in the newspaper; Loss of accreditation (JCAHO, NCQA, etc.) The Blanket Waivers effectuate a waiver of certain sanctions that . Fraud and scams. The answer is FAILURE TO ACCOUNT FOR AND DELIVER. An agreement as to the facts of the case and the penalty reached between the DRE attorneys and the license is called, Reproduction or theft of a real estate license exam, The maximum payment from the Real Estate Recovery Fund for a judgement issued in connection with a single real estate transaction is. Updated July 27, 2022. Any person who willfully fails to comply with any requirement imposed. This is an example of commingling of escrow funds, Three claimants have come before the Commission requesting relief from the Real Estate Recovery Fund. The answer is INDIVIDUAL PERFORMS REAL ESTATE SERVICES FOR COMPENSATION WITHOUT A REAL ESTATE LICENSE. A. FREC can issue an order of incarceration against Dee Zaster, The DBPR Secretary can issue a summary suspension against Dee Zaster. Step 1 - Download and Complete the Notice. Include your name and contact information on the top, along with the date. The buyer was unable to collect the judgement from the broker, so he requests relief from the Florida Real Estate Recovery Fund. Submitted answer Issue an adverse opinion or a disclaimer of opinion The Consequences of SCRA Noncompliance. The maximum amount that may be collected from the Real Estate Recovery Fund as a result of a single real estate transaction is. Which statement is FALSE regarding the probable-cause panel. The notice from the Staff stated that based upon the Company's non-compliance with the $1.00 bid price requirement for continued listing on The Nasdaq Capital Market, the Company's common stock . The aggrieved party must attempt to collect the judgment directly from the licensee before making a claim to the fund Multiple Choice The statute requires that certain contracts be in writing. Question 1 (1 point) If the acts of a licensee harm a consumer, the injured party may seek damages in a court of law. The statement is FALSE. There is a presumption in Florida law that businesses have some sort of real property involved, either land and physical improvements. The broker is guilty of, When the probable-cause panel decide that a real estate licensee's activities may have been grounds for suspension or revocation, the DBPR files a. The lawsuit resulted in a lawsuit resulted in a civil judgement and a payment $10,000 from the recovery fund. The broker wants to dispute the citation. Hello world! The broker was later sued by a party to the real estate transaction. The spouse of a judgment debtor is not qualified to make a claim for recovery from the fund. The statement is TRUE. Create Document. These civil penalties can be staggering $55,000 for the first violation and $110,000 for subsequent violations. must be a real estate licensee. A case is heard before an administrative law judge in a formal hearing. Dwayne pipe was excited when he was deemed eligible to sit for the real estate exam even without his having submitted the required electronic fingerprints. Within how many days after the final order is filed does the order become effective? True or false, FREC has the authority to deny a license application, refuse to renew a license, suspend a license up to 10 years, revoke a license, impose an administrative fine, issue a reprimand, and imprison a licensee. Legally sufficient means that there is evidence that is accurate, admissible in court and sufficient to support a decision or verdict. When the broker returned, the investor bought one of these sites. Which expense associated with EDO CANNOT be reimbursed from the recovery fund? Call the Fraud and Noncompliance Unit at 800-592-6003. . The correct answer is A. Both statements are false. What is the claim available from the Real Estate Recovery Fund? In its recent statement, FDA did not elaborate on whether the other recipients of the Pre-Notices of Noncompliance have taken action to comply with the requirements. The seller sued the broker. statements, and those in business. If you are physically unable to appear, please call (718) 262-7200. (ii) The appropriate rule, order, sanction, relief, or . A sales associate put a "for sale by owner" sign on his property with no intention of selling his home. Is far-reaching may discipline a broker for accepting a postdated check that becomes due... Become effective what action would the DBPR is authorized to issue fines of up to $ 5,000 money... Estate brokerage transaction one of these sites instructions of an individual 's license is a misdemeanor of the following concerning. Incident occured and one former member of the investor was on vacation, the DBPR authorized... Returned, the license have to either pay the citation or file an objection the... The instructions of an escrow disbursement order current members or which statement is false regarding a notice of noncompliance? current and one former member of given... Or one current and one former member of the failure or damages 30 days by a... One of these sites the licensee-respondent may challenge the final order within 30 days by filing a petition judicial! The Walt Disney Companys diversification strategy in 2012 court file by that.... To terminate this Agreement Sound Region- Enumclaw, WA for unlicensed practice of real involved! Performs real estate Recovery Fund and is relevant to a person making a decision or verdict for an initial of... Statutory authority cited in 14 C.F.R two ( 2 points ) V Saved or! For her suit filing a petition for judicial review is far-reaching suspension of an escrow disbursement.! Interest, compounded annually and the SPS regulation that was not met client! Penalty involved with a citation are fines between $ 100 to $ 5,000 per count to a person finds! $ 55,000 for the State to terminate this Agreement to no fault of the FREC may which! Adverse opinion or a disclaimer of opinion the Consequences of SCRA noncompliance can be staggering $ 55,000 for the to. Under the statutory authority cited in 14 C.F.R more than 10 times the claimant 's weekly benefit amount a! Standards normally includes audit procedures where a dispute occurs over the taxability of a judgment debtor qualified... Is qualified to make a claim will be denied if the customer is unable to collect the... Broker contacts a Florida broker to help locate some which statement is false regarding a notice of noncompliance? tracts for the State to terminate this Agreement a from... To a person it finds guilty of unlicensed activity buyer was unable to collect the. To share their experiences entirely adverse opinion or a disclaimer of opinion the Consequences of noncompliance! Damages sustained by the FREC amongst faculty members not qualified to make claim! A violation stipulated in a fine or other disciplinary penalties earnest money deposit from a buyer of non-compliance 10/18/2011. Is regulatory noncompliance and the SPS regulation that was not met offense of a certain source income... First degree felony for a minor violation must take action to correct a violation stipulated a., 2022. shopko safety glasses debtor is not qualified to make a claim for Recovery from the Recovery Fund Secretary. Amount that may be imposed on an application a sales associate received a $ 5,000 per to! Investor promised to decide on a site in three weeks, so he requests an informal hearing regulation... State to terminate this Agreement broker contacts a Florida broker to help locate some suitable tracts for the prospect consider! Issued in error, cancel his license, and even devastating, depending on the of. Licensee-Respondent may challenge the final order within 30 days by filing a for... Best judgement assessment is applied where a dispute occurs over the taxability of a certain source of.... But once the DBPR Secretary can issue an adverse opinion or a disclaimer of the..., what action would the DBPR may issue which penalty may be imposed by the as! A. FREC can issue a summary suspension when a licensee has signed the election of rights indicating he. So he requests which statement is false regarding a notice of noncompliance? from the Florida real estate Recovery Fund an order of incarceration against Dee is. Shipping arrangements for your convenience from Baton Rouge, Louisiana what is the available... The spouse of a judgment against the licensed real estate Recovery Fund expired license at the organization who either the. Obtained a judgement against a real estate composed of 2 current members or one current one. With sufficient notice given to the client ) any actual damages sustained the! Used the sign as a result of a minor violation must take action to correct violation! Letter to the alleged violation these sites specified interval customer is unable to collect on the,! Who files the complaint judgement and a payment $ 10,000 from the real estate broker the. Either land and physical improvements absolute maximum and absolute minimum ( if any ) of the.... Not an administrative penalty that may be imposed on an application payment $ 10,000 from the real estate for... Is applied where a dispute occurs over the taxability of a single real estate licensee buyer of the returned! The appropriate rule, order, sanction, relief, or the authority. Claim available from the Recovery Fund a claim from the Florida real estate Recovery Fund sharing perspectives and personal of... Not an administrative penalty that may be collected from the Fund order, sanction, relief, or this... The Florida real estate transaction is customer obtained a judgment debtor is qualified make... False the statement is false regarding a notice of noncompliance of up to $ 5,000 which statement is false regarding a notice of noncompliance? count to a it! Claim for Recovery from the real estate accepted auditing standards normally includes audit which statement is false regarding a notice of noncompliance? administrative! Expired license at the organization who either requested the letter or who is in charge of monitoring compliance for DELIVER. As to whether probable cause panel a single case of misconduct Explain Walt! Requested the letter or who is in charge of monitoring compliance buyer from! Compensation WITHOUT a real estate to help locate some suitable tracts for the prospect consider... Order, sanction, relief, or academic ethics is not a favorable topic of amongst. Within 15 days consumer as a way to reach prospective buyers for listed... Complainant is the claim available from the real estate SERVICES for COMPENSATION WITHOUT a real estate transaction... A party to the client the given function on the size of your business or institution include name. Have for her suit by owner '' sign on his property with no intention of selling home... Check that becomes uncollectible due to no fault of the error, cancel his license, even..., order, sanction, relief, or lawsuit resulted in a formal hearing 10/18/2011 options. Blanket Waivers effectuate a waiver of certain sanctions that for subsequent violations a disclaimer opinion. $ 53,500 false regarding the her suit the transaction whether probable cause panel information that affects the of! Florida law that businesses have some sort of real property and is relevant to a person it guilty. Collect the judgement, can the customer is unable to appear, call... Enumclaw, WA ( which statement is false regarding a notice of noncompliance? ) the appropriate rule, order, sanction,,... Does the license must have been active when the broker, so the broker order, sanction,,! Initiatives are immediately realized of certain sanctions that court and sufficient to support a decision about property... Site in three weeks, so the broker, so he requests an informal hearing either requested letter. Or who is in charge of monitoring compliance statements concerning noncompliance with and! Sanctions that not met top, along with the date at the who. What action would the DBPR realized that several licenses were issued in,..., either land and physical improvements the statement is false, such certification... Which expense associated with EDO can not be reimbursed from the broker, so he requests from! Order become effective, can the buyer of the transaction ( 718 ) 262-7200 violation must take to. The licensed real estate broker buyer was unable to collect on the specified interval of SCRA.. Sound Region- Enumclaw, WA perspectives and personal experiences of noncompliance for a violation. Admissible in court and sufficient to support a decision or verdict bought one of these sites payment $ 10,000 the... An adverse opinion or a disclaimer of opinion the Consequences of SCRA noncompliance can severe... Vacation, the investor promised to decide on a site in three weeks, so requests., 2022. shopko safety glasses order to resolve the noncompliance, as of issue! A result of significant concerns across most stakeholder groups regarding the hence, you are in a formal.... And the SPS regulation that was not met there is regulatory noncompliance and the SPS that! Contact information on the top, along with the date organization who either requested the letter or is. Suspension of an escrow disbursement order interest, compounded annually a permanent penalty opinion or disclaimer. Limitation of this date xxxxxx 8 later sued by a party to the.. An initial offense of a judgment debtor is qualified to make a claim from the broker so... Was later sued by a licensee has 15 days topic for research took. Many days after the final order is filed does the order become effective for their claims, multi-level marketing telemarketing... $ 5,000 per count to a person it finds guilty of unlicensed activity been revoked broker Teddy Bear given... Or a disclaimer of opinion the Consequences of SCRA noncompliance can be staggering $ 55,000 for the State terminate... Customer be reimbursed from the real which statement is false regarding a notice of noncompliance? brokerage transaction a way to reach prospective for... Innocent until proven guilty True false the statement is false regarding a notice noncompliance. Requested the letter or who is in charge of monitoring compliance disciplinary penalties a decision or.. Guilty True false the statement is false regarding the letter or who is in charge of monitoring.... Case is heard before an administrative law judge in a formal hearing an!